MARION COUNTY, Florida – A 54-year-old Florida man was sentenced to two consecutive life terms in prison after a jury found him guilty of the premeditated murder and kidnapping of a British woman who traveled to Florida in October 2025 and was later found buried in a shallow grave.
Dwain Chadwick Hall was convicted of premeditated first-degree murder and kidnapping in the death of 32-year-old Sonia Exelby, a resident of Portsmouth, England, according to the State Attorney’s Office for Florida’s Fifth Judicial Circuit.
Following the jury’s verdict on November 20, 2026, Judge Timothy McCourt adjudicated Hall guilty and sentenced him to two consecutive life sentences, meaning the sentences will be served one after the other.
British Woman Reported Missing After Flying to Florida
The investigation began on October 13, 2025, when the Florida Department of Law Enforcement’s Gainesville Field Office received a request for assistance from Interpol concerning Exelby, who had been reported missing and endangered.
Authorities in the United Kingdom, including the Hampshire & Isle of Wight Constabulary, determined that Exelby had flown to Gainesville, Florida, three days earlier.
Investigators reviewed her recent credit card transactions and discovered a payment for an Airbnb rental property in Reddick, Florida.
FDLE agents searched the rental property while continuing to examine transactions associated with Exelby’s account.
Among those transactions were multiple declined charges involving an auto repair business owned and operated by Hall.
Investigators Discover Two Years of Communication
Detectives began investigating Hall, who initially denied knowing Exelby.
However, cellphone and online records revealed that Hall and Exelby had been communicating for approximately two years.
Investigators also learned that Exelby had experienced mental health issues.
According to prosecutors, Hall picked up Exelby at Gainesville Regional Airport after she arrived in Florida and drove her to the Airbnb rental property.
Investigators determined that Hall had purchased several items, including rope and a shovel, before Exelby’s arrival.
The purchases later became significant evidence in the murder investigation.
Victim’s Body Found Buried in Marion Oaks
On October 17, 2025, investigators discovered Exelby’s body buried in a shallow grave in a wooded area of Marion Oaks.
The discovery followed an investigation involving FDLE, the Marion County Sheriff’s Office and law enforcement authorities in the United Kingdom.
While examining the burial site, crime scene personnel recovered a label associated with a shovel.
Investigators matched the label to a purchase receipt connected to Hall. Surveillance footage also captured the purchase.
Authorities later recovered the shovel from Hall’s residence.
Forensic testing revealed blood on the shovel’s handle that matched Exelby’s blood, according to prosecutors.
An autopsy determined that Exelby had suffered four sharp-force injuries, and her death was ruled a homicide.
Knife Mailed Out of State Identified as Murder Weapon
As investigators continued gathering evidence, they discovered that Hall had mailed a knife to a friend in another state.
Authorities recovered the knife and determined that it was the weapon used to kill Exelby.
Hall was subsequently arrested and charged with her murder and kidnapping.
The physical evidence, financial records, surveillance footage and communications between Hall and Exelby became central to the investigation that led to his conviction.
Prosecutors Secure Two Consecutive Life Sentences
Assistant State Attorneys Amy Berndt and Richard Buxman prosecuted the case.
The State Attorney’s Office credited the Marion County Sheriff’s Office, particularly Detective Joseph Miller, and FDLE investigators, including lead investigator Rebekah McKinzie, for their work.
Fifth Judicial Circuit State Attorney Bill Gladson described the case as deeply disturbing and expressed sympathy for Exelby’s family.
“This was an extraordinary and deeply disturbing case involving circumstances that are difficult to comprehend,” Gladson said.
“While no verdict can undo the unimaginable loss Sonia’s family has endured, we hope today’s outcome provides some measure of justice and allows them to begin the long process of healing.”
Gladson also emphasized the importance of recognizing vulnerability and looking out for others.
“Sonia’s life mattered, and she will not be forgotten,” he said.
Hall will serve two consecutive life sentences following his convictions for premeditated first-degree murder and kidnapping.
Source: State Attorney’s Office, Fifth Judicial Circuit of Florida, November 20, 2026

